Home Directories
Rankings
Journals
Forums
Resources
Maps
About Us
Login Register
Find Judge or Nominee
  
Search
  
  Welcome Guest  

Survey Journal
Survey Comments Posted at CourthouseForum.com and RateTheCourts.com

Survey comments for


Sun Dec 07 2008 - Tue Jan 06 2009

Federal(16)
Alabama(9)
Alaska
Arizona(1)
Arkansas(4)
California(74)
Colorado(3)
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia(4)
Florida(20)
Georgia(10)
Guam
Hawai'i
Idaho
Illinois(8)
Indiana(1)
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky(1)
Louisiana(1)
Maine
Maryland(2)
Massachusetts(8)
Michigan(15)
Minnesota(3)
Mississippi(1)
Missouri(1)
Montana
Nebraska(1)
Nevada
New Hampshire(4)
New Jersey(5)
New Mexico(4)
New York(15)
North Carolina(3)
North Dakota
Ohio(6)
Oklahoma(2)
Oregon
Pennsylvania(10)
Puerto Rico
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee(4)
Texas(16)
Utah(2)
Vermont(1)
Virgin Islands
Virginia(2)
Washington(13)
West Virginia(3)
Wisconsin(1)
Wyoming

 Federal
Judge Samuel Der-Yeghiayan
Total Surveys (11) B (3.16) All Survey Comments (9)
2008-12-20 A (4.00) Unquestionably, an extremely fair and efficient judge.

2008-12-27 A (4.00) An extremely talented and fair judge.
Bankruptcy Judge A. Benjamin Goldgar
Total Surveys (15) F (0.32) All Survey Comments (14)
2008-12-19 ---- (-1.00) Terrible judge. He has no clue what he's doing. Easily the worst bankruptcy judge in the district, if not the circuit.

2008-12-19 F (0.00) Goldgar is in love with the sound of his own voice. He ought to abandon the stand-up routine and try to act like a judge for ... [more]
Judge Stanley Marcus
Total Surveys (11) F (0.03) All Survey Comments (11)
2008-12-21 F (0.00) for sale or rent .

2008-12-27 F (0.00) CONGENITALY CORRUPT .

2008-12-27 F (0.00) CONGENITALY CORRUPT .

2008-12-27 F (0.00) CONGENITALY CORRUPT .

2009-01-04 F (0.00) sleazy and odorous .

2009-01-06 F (0.00) He is a semi-literate thief , in robes .
Judge Kenneth A. Marra
Total Surveys (8) D+ (1.33) All Survey Comments (7)
2008-12-16 F (0.00) He is obviously corrupt and does not care that everyone knows of his bias and lack of candor .
Magistrate Judge Barry S. Seltzer
Total Surveys (10) F (0.00) All Survey Comments (10)
2008-12-16 F (0.00) Rude , ignorant , corrupt and arrogant .

2008-12-16 F (0.00) A thief among thieves . Completely without dignity or common sense .

2008-12-17 F (0.00) THE BROWARD BAR produces so many of these parasites .

2008-12-24 F (0.00) MEYER LANSKY PROTEGE .
Judge James Nugent
Total Surveys (1) A (3.87) All Survey Comments (1)
2008-12-23 A (3.87) Even though Judge Nugent is one of the infamous "Bush appointees" to the Immigration Court, he is a hard worker who ... [more]
 Alabama
Judge Sibley G. Reynolds
Total Surveys (3) F (0.20) All Survey Comments (2)
2008-12-21 F (0.00) Bases decision on hearsay not facts. Is totally out of control.
Judge Jimmy Sandlin
Total Surveys (2) F (0.14) All Survey Comments (2)
2008-12-27 F (0.00) This judge has no concept of Alabama Law whatsoever. He held a custody hearing, without proper notice to the other party, de ... [more]

2009-01-02 F (0.28) Judge Jimmy Sandlin's actions and rulings appear to disregard the laws of our state. Sandlin pushed his personal agenda i ... [more]
Judge Thomas Young
Total Surveys (1) F (0.00) All Survey Comments (1)
2008-12-11 F (0.00) He is Bias, and unfair
Judge James C. Cashion
Total Surveys (8) F (0.10) All Survey Comments (7)
2009-01-04 F (0.04) Not a judge who knows what he is doing. Gave husband 3 weeks to get to him what was dated june of the year. Court was July. M ... [more]

2009-01-04 F (0.00) Not for the femaie. It was very obvious he had made his decision before he got to the courtroom... A rip off judge... This wi ... [more]

2009-01-04 F (0.00) Hope and pray you do not have to be female and in Divorce court with this jerk!!!Will talk to you like a dog and give everthi ... [more]

2009-01-06 ---- (-1.00) You should pray if your a woman that you never have to go up in front of this man.He will be little you and give everything t ... [more]
Judge George R. Greene
Total Surveys (1) C (2.00) All Survey Comments (1)
2008-12-18 C (2.00) My comments are based on some of his casees. Different strokes for different folks. Everyone is just a criminal. It's bad ... [more]
 Arizona
Judge Mark F. Aceto
Total Surveys (1) D (0.77) All Survey Comments (1)
2008-12-11 D (0.77) This Judge was bias, unfair, and I believe he was part of a conspiracy.
 Arkansas
Judge Xollie Duncan
Total Surveys (2) F (0.21) All Survey Comments (1)
2009-01-06 F (0.00) I feel Xollie Duncan doesn't act as a fair, just judge. She doesn't listen to both sides, and doesn't allow both sides to hav ... [more]
Judge Robert Abney
Total Surveys (3) F (0.00) All Survey Comments (2)
2008-12-09 ---- (-1.00) This judge is on drugs or something as he cannot understand anything. He also took the defendants "hearsay" testim ... [more]

2008-12-10 ---- (-1.00) This man is not a commpent judge. He ruled a person was given my bird but not my cage.What good is an empty cage gonna do me ... [more]
Judge Robert Batton
Total Surveys (2) F (0.36) All Survey Comments (2)
2008-12-24 F (0.00) Batton's personal relationship with police officers is inappropriate and a conflict of interest. Police officers can go to Ba ... [more]
 California
Commissioner Josanna Berkow
Total Surveys (39) F (0.15) All Survey Comments (32)
2009-01-06 F (0.00) This Commissioner who is not even a real Judge. Is suffering from her own severe delusions of grandeur.

2009-01-06 F (0.00) This Commissioner who is not even a real Judge. Is suffering from her own severe delusions of grandeur.

2009-01-06 F (0.00) This Commissioner who is not even a real Judge. Is suffering from her own severe delusions of grandeur.

2009-01-06 F (0.00) This Commissioner who is not even a real Judge. Is suffering from her own severe delusions of grandeur.
Commissioner Jeff Huffaker
Total Surveys (10) C (1.72) All Survey Comments (7)
2008-12-16 D- (0.68) Judge Huffaker is highly influenced by high-powered counsel. He denies even adequate counsel to pro per litigants. Violates t ... [more]
Judge Mary Ann Murphy
Total Surveys (1311) F (0.04) All Survey Comments (150)
2008-12-08 F (0.00) THIS JUDGE "Mary Ann Murphy"IS BIASED.SHE IS THE WORST AND A BAD JUDGE.SHE IS NOT FAIR AND A "DISGRACE TO THE ... [more]

2008-12-10 F (0.00) Judge Mary Ann Murphy is intolerable in her performance. She and her abusive, Errors of Law and Bias interpretation repeatedl ... [more]

2008-12-10 F (0.00) JUDGE MARY ANN MURPHY IS ACTING IN VERY DOUBTFUL MANNERS. SHE IS BEYOND DOUBT A “SCANDAL TO OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM".

2008-12-10 F (0.00) JUDGE MARY ANN MURPHY IS ACTING IN VERY DOUBTFUL MANNERS. SHE IS BEYOND DOUBT A “ SCANDAL TO OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM”.

2008-12-10 F (0.00) JUDGE MARY ANN MURPHY IS ACTING IN VERY DOUBTFUL MANNERS. SHE IS BEYOND DOUBT A “SCANDAL TO OUR JUDICIAL SYSTEM”.

2008-12-14 F (0.00) THIS DANGEROUS JUDGE MARY ANN MURPHY “Committed Dishonesty, errors of law and behave heartlessly" against the "fact ... [more]

2008-12-15 F (0.00) Superior Court Judge MARY ANN MURPHY ‘Unblemished Record’ The judge said she has an “unblemished record” and “works very har ... [more]

2008-12-16 F (0.00) THE PREJUDICE Judge Mary Ann Murphy "judicial misconduct":-ERRORS OF LAW- You should consider a Judge bad only if t ... [more]

2008-12-17 F (0.00) I AGREE, THAT Judge Mary Ann Murphy DID Not Do the necessary "homework" and being prepared for cases or Being consi ... [more]

2008-12-17 F (0.00) Performance Evaluation for Judge Mary Ann Murphy:"NO QUALIFICATIONS TO BE A JUDGE". SHE IS "DISHONEST,BAD JUDG ... [more]

2008-12-19 F (0.00) Filed 10/29/08 CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT DIVISION ... [more]

2008-12-19 F (0.00) · IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SECOND APPELLATE ... BC313464) APPEAL from an order of the Superior Cou ... [more]